Egyptian Tomb

Showing posts with label Greek Classics and Mythology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Greek Classics and Mythology. Show all posts

Thursday, August 4, 2011

The Epic Tragedy Part III: The Beginning of Athenian Law As Shown In The Oresteia

This will be my final post on Aeschylus’ trilogy the Oresteia. I really enjoyed going through this Greek classic and showing that in these classics we can see Greek culture, lifestyle, and thought. Through the stories, epics, and myths used in all cultures we are able to see how people in that culture truly lived, worshiped their gods, and even their habits and thoughts. We see that just from their artwork and writing how the Egyptians truly lived, and we see the same thing from the Greek classics. We can come to learn everything about their culture, even how they ate and dressed, through these classics and also through the Mythology. This can be seen in many ancient cultures other than Greece, but going through Aeschylus’ work we are able to see this clearly.

Here I will give a synopsis of the last play in the Oresteia tragedy, The Eumenides. Unlike the other two plays where the gods are only mentioned in The Eumenides the gods play significant roles. The play begins with the oracle of Apollo praying, giving us a hint of what is to come, and when she leaves we find Orestes and the furies at the temple. Orestes is not bothered by the furies because they had been put to sleep by the god Apollo, and as we saw in the second play of the Oresteia it was Apollo who had drove Orestes to avenge his father. So Apollo kept his word that he wouldn’t fail Orestes in the fact that he is protecting Orestes from the Furies here. Apollo tells Orestes that he must keep moving until he reaches the citadel of Pallas, which is another name used for Athena, and Apollo sends Hermes with Orestes. Orestes follows Apollo’s orders and leaves following Hermes. After they leave the ghost of Clytaemnestra arrives and tries to wake the Furies, which takes some time, but when the Leader of the Furies finally awakes she awakes the rest. Apollo comes out from his sanctuary and is infuriated at the Furies for desecrating his temple and they leave, not because his threats, but to continue their hunt for Orestes. They find him at the citadel of Pallas hugging the knees of the goddess and praying. The Furies circle around him getting ready for the kill while Orestes prays to Athena for help. Athena shows up to see the Furies poised to kill Orestes who is hugging her knees. The Leader of the Furies tells Athena That Orestes killed his mother and Athena listens to the Fury respectfully but then says “Two sides are here, and only half is heard.”(Aeschylus The Eumenides, p. 250. Lines 440). She then turns to Orestes to hear his side of the story, and when hearing both sides of the story she then decides that the case should be properly judged. She tells both sides to call for their witnesses to come forth, and also to gather their evidence, while she would gather ten citizens of Athens to judge the matter. In the end Orestes is found not guilty and is let free. Athena persuades the Furies to give up their occupation of hunting and killing to work under her as peace-makers. Justice becomes what it was truly meant to be and the Furies become the rightful protectors of justice, which is what they were truly meant to be. So in this three part tragedy the ending turns out for the better. Orestes is let free to go back to Argos and rule, the Furies become the protectors of justice in the way they were meant to be, and “justice” itself evolves from its circular form into what would become one of the most developed judicial systems in the ancient world.

In the next two paragraphs I am going to deal with the idea of “justice” in the last play of Aeschylus’ trilogy, The Eumenides. We saw in my last post that in the first two tragedies “Justice” was circular in the fact that anyone who wanted revenge could call that revenge just, whether their intentions were truly just or not. We saw that Clytaemnestra, who killed Agamemnon for sacrificing their daughter, had other intentions than just this for killing her husband. Also the circular form of justice is seen with Clytaemnestra killing Agamemnon because he killed their daughter, and then Orestes killing Clytaemnestra to avenge his father, and the Furies chase Orestes to kill him for killing his own mother. In this last play of the Oresteia an example of how justice and law are viewed differently from the last two plays is shown, and also Aeschylus shows us that this was the start of a judicial system that become one of the most developed in ancient history. The court scene in The Eumenides takes place when the Furies find Orestes hugging the knees of the Athena’s statue in the citadel of Pallas. Athena comes into the citadel to find the Furies circled around Orestes, who is hugging the knees of her statue, and after hearing both sides of the story she tells them that the matter needs to be judged correctly. The Furies then ask Athena if she would judge the issue and she  states: “You would turn over responsibility to me, to reach the final verdict?” (p. 251. Lines 446-47). and the Leader of Furies answers by saying “Certainly. We respect you. You show us respect.” (p. 251. Lines 448-49). This court scene is very similar to our court of law today and I will be comparing the court scene in The Eumenides to our society’s judicial system. Athena informs the Furies that she will obtain ten of the best citizens in Athens to judge over the case: “Too large a matter, some may think, for mortal men to judge. But by all rights not even I should decide a case of murder – murder whets the passions. But since the matter comes to rest on us, I will appoint the judges of manslaughter, swear them in, and found a tribunal here for all time to come. My contestants, summon your trusted witnesses and proofs, your defenders under oath to help your cause. And I will pick the finest men of Athens, return and decide the issue fairly, truly – bound to our oaths, our spirits bent on justice.” (p.252-253. Lines 484-87, 497-505). We see here that Athena sets up the court room scene: both the Furies and Orestes are to bring their witnesses and evidence, Athena is the judge, and the ten men of Athens are the jury.

Athena first separates the Furies and Orestes and she stands in between them and the two urns which are to be used for the ballots for the final vote at the end of the trial. Athena tells all that are present: “And while this court of judgement fills, my city, silence will be best. So that you can learn my everlasting laws.” (p. 256. Lines 576-78). From the sentence above and this sentence “and found a tribunal here for all time to come.” (p. 253. Lines 498-99). Aeschylus is showing that this was the beginning of the new law and justice system in Athens that the Greeks would use for years to come, and that would be carried on into the Roman empire. The trial begins and Athena shows us that Orestes is the defendant, Apollo comes in as his witness (but also plays some major parts as Orestes attorney), she is the judge, and the Leader of the Furies is the prosecutor. “The trial begins! Yours [The Furies] is the first word – the prosecution opens. Start to finish, set the facts before us, make them clear.” (p. 256. Lines 588-90). The Furies start by questioning Orestes and they ask if he killed his mother, the woman that bare him, and their case is that it was unjust for him to kill his mother. Orestes doesn’t deny that he killed his mother, and that Apollo was the one to drive him on in avenging his father, but he brings up a valid point; the fact that he didn’t kill an innocent woman. “She had two counts against her, deadly crimes. She killed her husband – killed my father too.” (p. 258. Lines 606-08). So was it truly unjust for him to kill his mother, who was also a killer, to avenge his father? Orestes asks Apollo if what he did was just or not. Apollo replies by saying: “Just, I say to you and your high court, Athena.” (p. 259. Lines 620-21). He claims that the command to avenge Agamemnon came from Zeus, “This is his justice – omnipotent, I warn you. Bend to the will of Zeus. No oath can match the power of the Father.” (p. 259. Lines 626-28). The Furies issue is the “power” or “rank” of the mother, the fact that she was the one who bore Orestes, but Apollo’s case is the “power” and “position” of the father. So in a sense it is a trial of the matriarch vs. the patriarch, and who holds the highest status. The Leader of the Furies asks: “You’d force this man’s acquittal? Behold, justice [she says this mockingly]! Can a son spill his mother’s blood on the ground, then settle into his father’s halls in Argos?” (p. 260. Lines 660-62). Apollo answers the Fury with a key piece of evidence that turns the scales and aids in favor of Orestes. “The woman you call the mother of the child is not the parent, just a nurse to seed, the new-sown seed that grows and swells inside her. The man is the source of life – the one who mounts.” (p. 260. Lines 666-69). Apollo’s proof for this claim is Athena who was born out of Zeus himself without a mother. “The father can father forth without a mother. Here she [Athena] stands, our living witness. Child sprung full-blown from Olympian Zeus, never bred in darkness of the womb but such a stock no goddess could conceive.” (p. 261. Lines 673-77). Even though women were highly respected in Greek culture they were still seen as lower than the man, and this thought-frame is seen in this myth of Zeus giving birth to Athena; who was fully grown when she was born. But there are different versions of this story and in one of them Zeus wound up eating Athena’s mother while she was pregnant. From inside his belly Athena grew and one day Zeus had a “splitting” headache and told Hephaestus to split open his skull; and out comes Athena fully garbed in her war regalia. In this version of the myth we see that even though Zeus bore Athena into the world, he did not initially give birth to her. This was the turning point in the trial and after Apollo brings this piece of evidence before the court Athena calls for the votes from the “jury.” Orestes is acquitted and Athena offers the Furies a different form of occupation then the one they had, and they become what Athena calls the “guards of Athens,” (p. 273. 960). and instead of hate and fury they bring joy and peace; they become the Eumenides.

Different cultures had some form of law and justice within it, and that law was the basis of these societies and civilizations; whether it was monarchical or democratic like with Athens. Here I will show a good example of a judicial system used in another ancient society; Judaism. In the book of Exodus after the Israelites were let go from Egypt and after the parting of the sea, Moses led them to Mount Sinai and the wilderness. While there his Father-in-law, Jethro, came to meet him and the children of Israel. Jethro observed that people would line up from dawn to dusk to see Moses and have him judge their matters (Exodus ). Jethro asks Moses about this and why he is the only one to judge the people, and Moses’ replies: “When they have a matter, they come unto me; and I judge between one and another, and I do make them know the statutes of God, and his laws (Ex. 18:16, KJV).” Jethro tells Moses that this is not good and he offers him some advice on how to make judging easier for him: “Listen now to my voice; I will give you counsel, and God will be with you: Stand before God for the people, so that you may bring the difficulties to God. And you shall teach them the statutes and the laws, and show them the way in which they must walk and the work they must do. Moreover you shall select from all the people able men, such as fear God, men of truth, hating covetousness; and place such over them to be rulers of thousands, rulers of hundreds, rulers of fifties, and rulers of tens. And let them judge the people at all times. Then it will be that every great matter they shall bring to you, but every small matter they themselves shall judge. So it will be easier for you, for they will bear the burden with you. If you do this thing, and God so commands you, then you will be able to endure, and all this people will also go to their place in peace (Ex. -23, NKJV).” Moses takes his father-in-laws advice and sets this up as the way the nation of Israel is to take care of matters. This was the form of law and justice until the time of Saul when the people decided that they wanted to follow other culture’s footsteps and have a king to rule over them. The book of Judges deals with this form of judicial system that Moses set up, and the judges were placed to “rule” over the people of Israel. Here is an example of the judicial system that was put over Israel before the time of kings and the law turned monarchical.  
 


Monday, July 25, 2011

The Epic Tragedy Part II: A Circular Form of Justice; What Justice Was Before The Athenian Law and Judicial System

First, before I begin my post, I would like to apologize for taking so long to post the second part to Aeschylus’ trilogy. I have been sick and a little under the weather as of late and so couldn’t post as I wanted to. So I hope my readership will forgive me for my absence. Thank you.

Like with my last post I will be giving comparisons between Greek culture and life, and the classic epics written by Greek authors. I will provide a brief summary of Aeschylus’ second play in the Oresteia; The Libation Bearers. The play opens up with the exiled son, Orestes, back in Argos at his father’s grave. He regrets he wasn’t there for Agamemnon’s death. He cuts two locks of his hair and places them on the grave for a salutation, but he is interrupted by a group of women coming to the grave. Orestes and his friend hide behind the grave as Electra, his sister, and her slave women come bearing libations. A libation is a ritual of pouring a drink as an offering, and in this case it’s an offering to Agamemnon’s memory. Clytaemnestra had sent the Libation bearers to the grave, and we find out that the only reason she did so was because of a dream that scared her into doing so. She sent her daughter, Electra, to the grave with the libation but Electra doesn’t know what to say because she was sent by the woman who killed her father. She asks her slave women what she should say and the leader provides the words for her. She prays for an avenger whether man or god to avenge her father, and her prayer is answered. Electra discovers the locks of hair on Agamemnon’s grave and at first doesn’t speak out loud that she knows who the hair belongs to, because she doubts it, but then Orestes shows himself and even though she doesn’t believe it at first it is truly him. Then Orestes comes up with a plan to kill both his own mother and her lover, Aegisthus. Orestes claims he has to come up with a cunning plan to kill them because Clytaemnestra used cunning to kill Agamemnon. Orestes comes to the palace as a stranger and gives them news that Orestes is dead, but then when he gets them alone, which he planned out with the leader of the slave women, he kills them both. In the end of the play Orestes is scared because the Furies begin to chase him to avenge Clytaemnestra, because he has the blood of his mother on him. This is the story-line of Aeschylus’ second play in the Oresteia, The Libation Bearers, now I will go into the cultural comparisons between this epic tragedy and Greek life.
The fist cultural comparison I will make is the ritual of the Libations. As I said above the ritual of the libation is a cup filled with wine, oil, perfumes, honey, or any other kind of precious liquid, and then the holder of the libation pours it over a grave or alter for an offering to either a god or a spirit who has passed on. In this play the libation is for the spirit of Agamemnon, and his daughter Electra is the holder of the cup. Clytaemnestra wouldn’t have sent such a sacrifice if she had not received a dream that scared her into sending the Libation Bearers. Electra, speechless of what prayer to offer her father, asks what she should say: “What kindness, what prayer can touch my father? Shall I say I bring him love for love, a woman’s love for husband? My mother, love from her? I’ve no taste for that, no words to say as I run the honeyed oil on father’s tomb.”[1] She asks her slave women for help in what to pray as she pours her sacrifice over her father’s grave, and the leader tells her to ask the gods for “The one who murder’s in return.”[2] Electra does as the leader suggests and prays for the gods and her father to send her brother: “O bring Orestes home, with a happy twist of fate, my father…… For our enemies I say, Raise up your avenger, into the light, my father – kill the killers in return, with justice!”[3] Many cultures used libations as a religious ritual, and one of those cultures was Judaism; we can see in the Old Testament. In Genesis Jacob uses a sort of libation to pour over the alter he made at the place he called Beth-el. “And Jacob set up a pillar in the place where he talked with him [God], even a pillar of stone: and he poured a drink offering thereon, and he poured oil thereon (Genesis 35:14, KJV).”

Next we see in The Libation Bearers, what I talked about in my last post, but will improve upon, the view of women in Greek culture. As I stated in my last post the Greeks view of women was high, and this can be seen in all of the Greek epics in one form or another. Whether the woman is the Heroine or the antagonist, or even a goddess, most of the women in the Greek classics are intelligent and clever. In The Libation Bearers I will show three different types of women that Aeschylus’ places in his play. First we’ll look at Clytaemnestra the murderess of her husband, and mother of Orestes and Electra. I showed her intelligence in my last post with setting up the “Beacons.” Orestes states that she and Aegisthus will die by the same cunning they used to kill his father: “They killed an honoured man by cunning, so they die by cunning, caught in the same noose.”[4] But in fact we saw in the first play that the one who really set up Agamemnon’s murder was in fact Clytaemnestra and not Aegisthus. The second women I will show is the leader of the slave women. Even as a slave she shows how much knowledge she has by giving words to Electra and also by being used in Orestes plan. He encourages the Leader to tell his old nurse, when she was sent to get Aegisthus (for Orestes, disguised as a stranger, urged for Aegisthus to be brought to the guest room so that he could talk “man to man” with him about Orestes death), that the nurse should get Aegisthus to come alone; without his bodyguard. If it was not for the Leader’s part, Orestes plan would not have worked. We see that her knowledge comes from experience because she is an older woman “We’re old. You’re young, now you teach us.”[5] We see the difference between this slave and the Queen, but nonetheless both portray a form of intelligence. The final woman in Aeschylus’ The Libation Bearers is Orestes sister Electra. Electra in the play seems to be blinded by her grief to think straight and even when she figures out that Orestes is back in Argos, and has been at the grave, she doesn’t believe it at first. But nonetheless she was the one who discovered his return. Orestes even scolds her for being slow for not realizing that it is really him: “Open your eyes. So slow to learn. You saw the lock of hair I cut in mourning. You scanned my tracks, you could see my marks, your breath leapt, you all but saw me in the flesh – Look – put it [the lock of hair] where I cut it. It’s your brother’s. Try, it matches yours.”[6] All of these women play significant roles in Aeschylus’ play and having women in such roles gives us insight into Greek thought, and how women were viewed and treated in the Greek civilizations.  

The final comparison to be made is the presence of oracles in the epics and their role in the religious rituals of ancient Greece. Oracles are used in many of the Greek epics and oracles are mainly played as female characters. (Again we see how women played a significant part in the epics and in Greek life). Oracles were priestesses of a god’s temple and were the mediator between the gods and the humans; they were the voice of the god they served. One of the most important Oracles in the Greek epics was the Priestess of Apollo, the Pythia, who is mentioned often as the Oracle at Delphi. She is the oracle that is used in Aeschylus’ trilogy. We find out in The Libation Bearers that Orestes did not come to avenge his father just for himself, but that he was sent by Apollo to do it. The Oracle, the Pythia, was the voice of Apollo to Orestes and told him to avenge Agamemnon. Orestes tells Electra and the slave women this and that this is the reason he is back in Argos: “Apollo will never fail me, no, his tremendous power, his oracle charges me to see this trial through. I can still hear the god – a high voice ringing with winters of disaster, piercing the heart within me, warm and strong, unless I hunt my father’s murderers, cut them down in their own style – they destroyed my birthright. ‘Gore them like a bull!’ he called, ‘or pay their debt with your own life, one long career of grief.’ Such oracles are persuasive, don’t you think? And even if I am not convinced, the rough work of the world is still to do. So many yearnings meet and urge me on. The god’s commands. Mounting sorrow for father.”[7] The oracle that is mentioned plays a part in the third play of Aeschylus’ trilogy as well, The Eumenides. In fact the play begins with the Pythia’s prayer (Aeschylus The Eumenides, p.231-233. 1-66). Oracles were greatly esteemed in Greek culture as well as priests, priestess, and seers. All of these occupations dealt with, in some form or another, service to the gods. It was not uncommon for the Greek, and even Roman, people to get spiritual and future advice from those who were in service to the gods. In fact in Roman culture you would consult seers for the perfect day for you to get married and other ceremonial events. Oracles, and all other religious figures, were highly respected because they were looked at as the voice of the gods.

The final thing I will talk about, which is the reason for my title, is the view of justice and law before the Athenian judicial system. During Aeschylus’ time-frame for his tragedies he shows how justice and law worked before his own era’s judicial system. In the time of Aeschylus the Athenian law and form of justice was similar to our judicial system and court of laws. In my next post I will go into detail about the Athenian justice system, and the third play of the Oresteia gives us a detailed example of how this worked. But in this section I will be looking at the form of “justice” before this particular court arrangement. Law and justice was put in the hands of everyone, even though there were Elders (as we saw with the Old Men in the first play, Agamemnon) who were supposed to judge matters they’re judgment could only go so far. This type of “justice” was circular and we see this in the Oresteia. Why in the first play of the trilogy does Clytaemnestra kill her husband, and Cassandra? Because he sacrificed their daughter to appease the gods for safe travel to Troy, and so she waited, hoping he would return unharmed, so that she could get her revenge; she thought this was justice. Then Orestes, their son, is told by the god Apollo to avenge Agamemnon and kill his murderers; who are Aegisthus and his mother. This he does and he believes he is doing the right and just thing, but the furies come to kill him for murdering his own mother. This then is the view of justice in the first two plays, and it’s circular, “Eye for an eye and tooth for a tooth” kind of justice. In this form of justice there is no right over wrong or good over bad, so anyone is justified in thinking that they are right. Was Agamemnon right in sacrificing Iphigeneia? Was Clytaemnestra wrong to want revenge? Was Orestes justified in killing his mother? Orestes states: “Now force clash with force – right with right!” So we see that this form of “justice” is flawed, and even though in the last play the idea of “justice” changes we will see some flaws even in it. But for now in the Oresteia the “old form” of justice is circular and it comes to a point where even Orestes knows that if he kills his mother the effect of his cause will turn into someone, or something, killing him. The leader of the slave women mention: “’Word for word, curse for curse be born now,’ Justice thunders, hungry for retribution, ‘stroke for bloody stroke be paid. The one who acts must suffer.’”[8] The Leader urges Orestes to stay in Argos after he kills his mother but he knows that the Furies are after him and states that he must move on: “No, no! Women – look – like Gorgons, shrouded in black, their heads wreathed, swarming serpents! – Cannot stay, I must move on. You can’t see them I can, they drive me on! I must move on –“[9] This is where the second play in the Oresteia ends, and I will end this post here but I will continue to show the view of “justice” in my next post. Aeschylus shows us many things in his tragedies but one thing he wanted to show was the evolution of justice, and law and order, how it was before the Athenian judicial system and how it changed into the “justice system” that Athens came to use.           


[1] Aeschylus The Libation Bearers, p. 180. 87-91.
[2] Ibid, p. 182. 123.
[3] Ibid, p. 183. 143-44, 147-49.
[4] Ibid, p.202. 543-44.
[5] Ibid, p. 185. 174.
[6] Ibid, p. 188. 227-33.
[7] Ibid, p. 191-192. 272-81, 302-06.
[8] Ibid, p. 192. 316-20.
[9] Ibid, p. 225. 1047-50, 1060-61.

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

The Epic Tragedy Part I: Do The Greek Plays Accurately Display What Greek Culture Was Like?

I am going to go through all three of the tragedies in Aeschylus’ Oresteia, to show that the plays and poetry of the Greek writers portrays the culture in which they lived. The lifestyles, thoughts, rituals, and traditions that are depicted in Greek epics were the same for the Greeks at that time. I’m going to focus on how the Greeks viewed and worshiped their gods, and this part of Greek culture can be clearly seen in the plays and poetry from poets like Aeschylus, Homer, and Sophocles. Although Plato would disagree with me because he believed the poets misrepresented the gods; he had an understanding of god that most Christians today have. But why focus on this topic? Because I believe it will give a better understanding of why so many Romans and Greeks, after the death and resurrection of Christ, flocked to Christianity and its views.

The first play in the Oresteia trilogy is Agamemnon, which deals with the return of Agamemnon from the Trojan War after ten years. I will give a small summary of the play here. It takes place after the ten year war between the Greeks and the Trojans, all for a woman named Helen, and is set in Argos the home of Agamemnon. The wife of Agamemnon is informed about his return by a chain of torches, which she set up, that moved across the land from Troy to Argos. We see the same imagery used in the film The Lord of The Rings: The Return of The King, which displays the burning of the “Beacons” from Gondor to Rohan. Ten years ago, the Old Men tell us in the play, Agamemnon sacrificed his daughter to calm the seas for their travel. Clytaemnestra never forgave him for this, and we don’t see her maliciousness until the end of the play. Agamemnon returns, with the Priam’s daughter the seer Cassandra, and the end catapults. The moment Clytaemnestra has waited for, for ten years, has finally come; her chance to get “justice.” (I put the word “justice” with quotations because we will see in the rest of the trilogy different forms of that word. For Clytaemnestra “justice” is, as we would say, “an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth.” So a death for a death. We will find out in the later plays that justice will change. It is amazing to see that in Aeschylus’ trilogy the development of justice and the law formed into what it was during his era). Cassandra foretells of hers and Agamemnon’s death to the Old Men and the Leader. (The Old Men and the Leader are like what most clans and cultures had, the elders of the city, like a city council and they controlled the law and order in the city other then the king; and when the king wasn’t there). They don’t know whether to believe Cassandra or not, but the next scene when she goes into the palace they hear the cries of agony from Agamemnon and the future was revealed. When they finally go in to investigate they find both Agamemnon and Cassandra dead; just like Cassandra foretold. Clytaemnestra doesn’t even hide that it was her who murdered them, and she claims that she did it out of, what she declares as, “justice;” having blood for blood. But apparently she was not alone in her malicious plan, Aegisthus her lover and son of Thyestes, brother of Agamemnon’s father Atreus, was in on it with her. All because of what Atreus did to Thyestes' other son. In the end of the play the Leader of the Old Men challenges Aegisthus, but Clytaemnestra prevents them from more death and for now Aegisthus and Clytaemnestra rule the land of Argos.       

The first cultural comparison we can make between the Greek plays and Greek culture is the practice of prayer. Prayer was a ritual carried out in all homes and statuses in Greece; whether you were a priest or priestess, or just a simple house wife. This ritual is shown in many of the Greek’s writings and in Agamemnon the play begins with a prayer. There are many different types of prayers that are portrayed in this play, and I will give a few examples of this. The play starts out with a watchman who is fighting to stay awake. In the first line the gods are mentioned as the watchman prayers to them trying to keep his mind active (Aeschylus "Agamemnon", P.103-104. 1-42). This type of prayer to the gods would have been similar to the every day prayers that most Greeks of that time would’ve prayed. It is a pleading prayer, pleading for something to occur that would make the watchman’s life better, and what he asked for he received. The “Beacons” are lit and the Watchman’s pleading pray for the return of his king is answered; Troy is won and Agamemnon is returning to Argos. These types of prayers are seen in the Greek epics and are seen throughout the Oresteia. These pleading prayers are a cry out to the gods for intervention. Another type of prayer that is shown in Agamemnon is a prayer of thanks. A common phrase that is often used in the Greek epics is “Thank the gods,” which is a small prayer of thanks offered up kind of like when we would say “Thank God.” The Leader who asks Clytaemnestra about how she knew the Greeks won the war in Troy says: “We’ll thank the gods, my lady – first this story, let me lose myself in the wonder of it all!”[1] The last type of prayer I will show here is what Agamemnon does: a salutation to the gods for the conquering of Troy. “First, with justice I salute my Argos and my gods, my accomplices who brought me home and won my rights from Priam’s Troy – the just gods.”[2] These sorts of prayers are the basic prayers for any religion whether Dualistic or Monotheistic, So it probably wasn’t uncommon for those living during the time of Aeschylus to offer up these types of prayers.

Another cultural aspect that is shown in the Oresteia is the view the Greeks had about women. Where the prayers are a ritual aspect of Greek culture, this next comparison of the Greek epics to their culture deals with the thought-frame of the ancient Greeks. Unlike like most cultures where women were put down the Greeks educated their women until a certain age, and the Romans did as well. Even though women were still meant to be the overseer of the house they weren’t unlearned. Aeschylus shows us this with Clytaemnestra, on page 113 the Leader asks Clytaemnestra how she had news that the war in Troy was done and how she knew the Greeks won: “And who on earth could run the news so fast?”[3] She replies to his question by telling him about the beacons she set up from Troy to Argos: “The god of fire – rushing fire from Ida! And beacon to beacon rushed it to me, my couriers riding home the torch.”[4] Aeschylus shows that Clytaemnestra is quite intelligent for thinking up this plan, even though it’s also good for the plot, but by doing this he gives us insight into Greek thought. In Greek mythology there is equally tales about men and women, you have Hercules and then you have Psyche, heroes and heroines; with antagonists being both male and female. Also the gods were both male and female, you had gods and goddesses, and even the deity of wisdom is a goddess; Athena. Why would women be placed in such roles if the Greeks didn’t think highly of them? This goes to show that women had some sort of equality with men, and it was on the intellectual scale. We see Clytaemnestra’s intellect for setting up the “Beacons” from Troy to Argos, and we also see it in her plans to kill Agamemnon. The Romans gained this thought-frame from the Greeks; they borrowed a lot of their religion, thought, culture, and lifestyle from the Greeks. They even borrowed the Greek gods, although renaming them.

The final comparison I will make between Greek culture and the plays of the Oresteia is the ritual of worship. Why did the Greeks, and later the Romans, worship their gods? There were many different forms of religion in ancient cultures and many of people worshiped their gods for one reason alone; fear. This worship because of fear is seen quite a few times in Aeschylus’ Agamemnon, and this was the same type of worship for the Greek/Roman gods during the time Christianity came on the rise. In the end of this post I will show that because of this type of worship to the Greek/Roman gods many Romans flocked to Christianity because it is completely different from the religion they grew up believing. The first place in Agamemnon where we see this worship out of fear is when Clytaemnestra tells the Leader that she hopes for the safe return of Agamemnon. “The run for home and safety waits, the swerve at the post, the final lap of the grueling two-lap race. And even if the men come back with no offence to the gods, the avenging dead may never rest – Oh let no new disaster strike!”[5] She says this because she is afraid the gods that sided with the Trojans during the war, which this division of the gods can be seen in Homer’s Iliad, will avenge them and attack the victorious Greeks. The Old Men continue this type of reverence to the gods: “The reach for power can recoil, the bolt of god can strike you at a glance.”[6] The last scene where we see this type of worship is when Agamemnon returns and Clytaemnestra sets out, what you can say as, the “Red carpet” treatment for him. He refuses to walk upon the scarlet tapestries that she had set up for his arrival because he claims that it’s the kind of treatment a god should have, but not a man. “This – you treat me like a woman. Grovelling, gaping at me – What am I, some barbarian peacocking out of Asia? Never cross my path with robes and draw the lighting. Never – only the gods deserve the pomps of honour and the stiff brocades of fame. To walk on them…I am human, and it makes my pulse stir with dread. Give me the tributes of a man and not a god, a little earth to walk on, not this gorgeous work. There is no need to sound my reputation. I have a sense of right and wrong, what’s more – heaven’s proudest gift. Call no man blest until he ends his life in peace, fulfilled. If I can live by what I say, I have no fear.”[7] Clytaemnestra convinces him that it’s safe and he gives in, but not without first saying: “Hurry, and while I tread his splendours dyed red in the sea, may no god watch and strike me down with envy from o high.”[8] The ancient Greeks, and even the Romans, held the same view about the gods, that if you made any offence to the gods they would strike you down at their whim. They worshiped their gods out of fear but these deities they worshiped had humanistic characteristics and the humans would disagree with their actions, but they worshiped the deities anyways because of the fear. As the Old Men state: “First comes and the news is good, it races through the streets but is it true? Who knows?  Or just another lie from heaven?”[9] This shows that the deities of the Greeks, who had humanistic attributes, could do both virtue and vice. They can lie, steal, kill, and do any other vice that any human can do, so they were serving gods who had the same emotions, attributes, and characteristics as themselves, and the only reason they worshiped such gods is because they were afraid what would happen to them, their culture, and their entire civilization if they didn’t. These gods not only held vice and the ability, as we can say, to sin; but they were also unpredictable.

What makes the worship of these deities so different from the God of the Bible? How can we see that from this type of worship, which the Romans held to like the Greeks, why so many left these deities and turned to Christianity? Because the God of the Bible is completely different from the Greek gods. God is a loving god, and loved man so much that He sent His only son, Jesus Christ. Jesus was the manifestation of God’s love to man (1 John 4:9). Where the Greek gods would strike you down just for looking at them wrong. Who wouldn’t turn to the Christian God? Also God doesn’t have human vice, sin, like lying (Titus 1:2), and he can’t even sin at all (1 John 3:9), and lastly he’s not tempted like the Greek gods: “Let no man say when he is tempted, I am tempted of God: for God cannot be tempted with evil, neither tempteth he any man (James 1:13).” So we can clearly see the difference between the God of the Christians and the gods of the Greeks. With the Greek gods, god is made in man’s image instead of man being created in God’s image (Genesis ).


[1] Aeschylus Agamemnon, p.115. 319-20.
[2] Ibid, p.133. 794-97.
[3] Ibid, p.113. 280.
[4] Ibid, p.114. 281-83.
[5] Ibid, p.116. 346-51.
[6] Ibid, p.120. 461-62.
[7] Ibid, p.137-138. 911-26.
[8] Ibid, p.139. 942-45
[9] Ibid, p.120. 467-70.

Thursday, June 23, 2011

THE FAULTS OF THE IMMORTALS

Here is a paper I wrote few years ago for my Philosophy class, but I am currently reading The Orestia by Aeschylus and was thinking about writing a few posts on it. Because in alot of the classic's we see the characteristic of the gods of the Greeks and that is a subject that has always fasinated me, because the gods are portrayed as having the same human mannerisms as mortals; but yet they are immortals. So I hope you enjoy this paper:

                                        The Faults of the Immortals


The Greeks see their gods as stronger and powerful than any mortal man could be. The Greeks worship the deities because of this fact, and also because they fear what would happen to humankind if the gods didn’t give them support. But in many of the epics and other classical writings, or even in just the way they are worshipped, the deities themselves don’t seem very different from mortals. One of the only differences between the gods and mortals is the fact that the gods can’t die, but that doesn’t mean they can not be wounded. Many of the characteristics that the deities portray in the epics and classical Greek writings are very similar to that of a human, that they almost seem to have some sort of mortality, not in the fact that they can’t die but because they get angry or happy and hold other human emotions. The mortality of the deities is represented in their weakness, passions, and emotions. But to learn more about the deities, the way the Greeks believed the deities started, needs to be looked at to prove my point.

The mythology of the Greeks contains a variety of stories about the beginning of the gods. Homer says that the oldest god was named Okeanos, who was a river-god, and supposedly all things came from his river, and he is still in existence. “Ever since the time when everything originated from him he has continued to flow to the outermost edge of the earth, flowing back upon himself in a circle.”[1] This is the first part of the beginning of the gods. Sometimes the Titans are referred to as the first gods of mythology and from the Titans came the Olympian who are the most famous of the gods in mythology. Zeus, who is called Jupiter by the Romans, was the one who stood against the Titans and destroyed them. “Before the Olympian Gods were born, the Titans reigned, first-born of Heaven and Earth. Jupiter conquered them after they had devoured his son Dionysus Zagreus, and from their ashes he made mankind.”[2] Zeus then became the highest of the gods and he is the one that started the Olympian gods, who are famous among the Greeks and Romans alike. Zeus is a good god to look at to see the characteristics that the Greeks believed the deities had. He was not just above the rest of the gods because of what he accomplished with the Titans, but also because of the power he possessed. Because of the deities in Greek mythology it’s easy for a poet like Homer to portray the humanistic characteristics they hold. “The human Zeus of Homer scarcely commands admiration; he is shamelessly licentious, he bullies and even maltreats his wife; when his will is crossed, he is apt to behave like an uncontrolled thunderstorm; but there are beginnings of higher things, specially in the kindly aspect of Zeus as God of strangers, suppliants and even beggars.”[3] Homer and other poets gave the deities the same virtues and vices as the humans in many of the epics, and this makes the gods very similar to humans; the only difference is gods cannot die.

            The virtues that are shown in the epics were the same virtues that the Greeks held to, such as justice, wisdom, and honor. For the Greeks justice was carried out in a way,  that who ever did any wrong would get punished for it, “A product of this kind of justice is the ius talionis which was usual in early times and finds pregnant expression in the saying ‘an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth’.”[4]As for wisdom, the Greeks believed that to gain wisdom you had to live a life full of both moral and intellectual virtues. “Let us suppose for a moment that the Greeks have convinced us that we cannot live a fully human life without acquiring both the moral virtues and the intellectual virtues.”[5] Both of these virtues, and honor and pride as well, are shown in the epics through both the mortals, and the deities. For the gods to have the same virtues as the humans in the epics gives them a humanistic mannerism. But not only did the deities have the same virtues in the epics as the mortals, but also the same emotions. “The gods of Homer’s Iliad take out their anger actively, as in the poet’s descriptions of the destructive fire unleashed by the thunderbolt of Zeus.”[6] These characteristics that the poets gave the deities are best shown in the Iliad, where the gods took either the Greeks side or sided with Troy in the Trojan War. Looking at the gods in the Iliad we see that they held human kind very highly, so much so that the gods gave strength or help to the men they sided with. “Athena made him bold, and gave him ease to tower amid Argives, to win glory, and on his shield and helm she kindled fire most like midsummer’s purest flaming star in heaven rising, bathed by the Ocean stream.”[7] This is also shown when Aphrodite puts herself in harms way, many times, to help those from her side. Like when she went on the battlefield to check on her men, while she was there Diomedes pierced her with his spear. Both of these stories in the Iliad show how the gods characterized honor and pride, and even emotions in helping who they favored. But the last story also shows something else, and that is even though the gods and deities in many of the epics and classics seem to have the same traits as humans they are in fact immortal. Because in the story of the Iliad with Diomedes piercing Aphrodite’s hand, it is seen that she can be injured but not killed and what flows from her veins is not blood. “Now from the goddess that immortal fluid, ichor, flowed – the blood of blissful gods who eat no food, who drink no tawny wine, and thereby being bloodless have the name of being immortal.”[8]

            The Greeks saw their gods as, always, immortal and that is why many Greeks did not like how the poets wrote that the gods had the same traits and characteristics as humans. One of those Greeks was Plato. Those who didn’t agree with the poets believed that if a soul was immortal than its nature would be god-like, and by being god-like that soul would not have  humanistic mannerisms. “If the soul is immortal, it must be in its essential nature like God; it must itself be a creature of the realm of Gods. When a Greek says “immortal” he says “God”: they are interchangeable ideas.”[9] But the idea of immortality wasn’t something new among the Greeks; in fact many cultures before the Greeks believed in Immortal deities, the Egyptians were one of them. Most of the worldviews around the time of the Greeks had their own deities they worshipped and gave offerings to. One of the things the Greeks and many other ancient cultures believed was since there were deities there was life after death, and because of this their lives then had a purpose on earth. This is still widely believed today. “But there is a more radical religious response to the claims that a future life gives our present life meaning and purpose, for implicit in such a belief is the notion that this purpose is God’s purpose for us.”[10] This is another view of what the Greeks believed that is shown in the human side of the epics and classics. Diomedes chose to follow Athena’s advice and take her gifts because he believed that what glory and honor he accomplished on earth would then help him in the afterlife. Another thing that is seen through the Iliad other than the differences between a mortal and an immortal is the bond that the deities had with mortals. The gods seem friendly to the humans they favored, and in the Iliad and many of the other epics it seems that each side has equal number of gods helping them. But for the humans of the epics, and even for the Greeks, the gods were not at all friendly and were meant to be worshipped. The Greeks worshipped their gods because they feared what would happen to humankind if the gods didn’t give them support. So this is why the worship of the gods was important to the Greek culture.

            This part of the Greek culture, worship of their deities, the rituals and prayers were shown in the epics and myths. Like offering a sacrifice to the temple, praying before going to war, or even going to an oracle for advice from the gods. “The original motives of sacrifice arise from three natural desires of man-first, to establish communion or kinship with the god-secondly, to ensure his favour, and thirdly, to escape his wrath.”[11] Like most other ancient cultures, the giving of sacrifices and other rituals of Greek worship had very specific instructions for them to perform. Since there were many different reasons for making a sacrifice the detailed instructions varied to whether you were making a sacrifice to praise a god or to try and escape the god’s wrath. One of these forms of sacrificing was a praise sacrifice which is called a donative sacrifice. “Its object was two-fold: firstly, to obtain favours, and secondly, to give thanks for favours received.”[12] Another part of the Greeks worship to the gods that is seen in many of the epics and classics, are the prayers that the mortals use to ask for help from the gods. This is seen a lot in epics like the Iliad where Homer makes the prayers elegant and lengthy. Like when Hektor said a prayer to Zeus for his son “O Zeus and all immortals, may this child, my son, become like me a prince among Trojans.”[13]Another Greek ritual of worship that is mentioned in many epics and classics is the Oracle; an Oracle was a speaker of the gods. Oracles were meant to be there for the god to speak through them and give advice to Greeks who came asking for something. The Oracle is mentioned in plenty of the classical writings and because of them it’s easy to see that the Oracle at Delphi was in power the most; she was the Oracle of the god Apollo. But no one knows when she, because most Oracles were female, started. “Yet despite the official recognition of a highly alien faith Apollo still reigned supreme at Delphi during the sixth century B.C., the defied embodiment of an attitude of mind.”[14]

            By looking at all the things mentioned, it is clear to see that the Greek’s held a very high view of their gods. Even though there were many Greek poets who wrote about the humanistic mannerisms of the gods. But for some, like Homer, even though they gave the gods the same virtues, weaknesses, and emotions of a human; they were still immortal. The gods also were still above the humans and this was portrayed well in many of the epics through the worship and rituals of the mortals. These were the same rituals that the Greeks practiced, and by reading the epics and classics we can see how Greek culture was lived out.


[1] C. Kerenyi, The Gods of the Greeks (New York: Grove Press, Inc., 1960), 15.
[2] Joscelyn Godwin, Mystery Religions: In the Ancient World (New York: Harper & Row, Publisher, Inc., 1981), 40.
[3] Jane Ellen Harrison, Mythology (New York: Cooper Square Publishers, Inc., 1963), 140.
[4] Martin Persson Nilsson, Greek Piety (New York: Oxford University Press, 1948), 35.
[5] Stringfellow Barr, The Three Worlds of Man (Columbia: University of Missouri Press, 1963), 58.
[6] Gregory Nagy, Homer: The Iliad (New York: Random House, Inc, 1974), xii.
[7] Homer Iliad, 5. 2-6.
[8] Ibid, 5. 41-5.
[9] Erwin Rohde, Psyche: The Cult Of Souls And Belief In Immortality Among The Greeks (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul LTD, 1925), 253.
[10] Paul and Linda Badham, Death and Immortality in the Religions of the World (New York: Paragon House Publisher, 1987), 6.
[11] S. C. Kaines Smith, The Elements of Greek Worship (London: Charles H. Kelly), 92.
[12] Ibid, 94.
[13] Homer Iliad, 6. 80-82.
[14] John Pollard, Seers Shrines and Sirens (London: Hertford and Harlow, 1965), 37.