Egyptian Tomb

Showing posts with label Exodus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Exodus. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Putting The Pieces Together Part VII: Did Other People Groups Join The Israelites On Their Exodus?




This is going to be my final post on Simcha Jacobovici’s documentary The Exodus Decoded. I have really enjoyed this video and blogging on it. I hope in the future to study and do more research on this era, because of the controversy surrounding the Exodus. I also desire to do more research on the Hyksos period to be able to show that they are not the Israelites. There are things that I’ve agreed with Jacobovici on, and then there were other things I didn’t. But it is encouraging, speaking as a Christian, to have someone do a documentary like this to try and prove that the Exodus really happened. We will look at two artifacts that Jacobovici believes can prove that the sea was parted, and by showing us these artifacts Jacobovici gets us to think that maybe the Israelites weren’t the only ones who left on the Exodus with Moses; could it be possible that other people groups went with them?

     Jacobovici is certain that the Israelites weren’t the only people to follow Moses on the Exodus, through the sea, and then later to Mount Sinai. But Jacobovici asserts that this was as far as this people group went with the Israelites, and again he finds the necessary evidence. “As it turns out some of the people that followed Moses across the parted sea, and later to Mount Sinai, did not follow him to the Promised Land. They boarded ships and sailed to an unknown exodus to Greece. Why hasn’t any noticed? Because no one has thought to look in Greece for evidence of an event that happened in Egypt. In fact, until recently, there was very little archaeological evidence of contact between the Minoan civilization of ancient Greece and Egypt at the time of Moses. All that changed with two great discoveries: The first was in 1972 when digging under the ash at Santorini Archaeologist made a startling discovery, linking this area of the world with the Exodus. They found unusual Minoan style wall paintings, incredibly among them there is a map depicting an ancient journey from Egypt to Greece.” Jacobovici continues with his description about the map: “The map is breathtaking, the colors as vibrant today as 3500 years ago. It depicts an epic journey from Egypt to Santorini. The voyage is complete with a terrible storm at sea. Working even further back we see that ancient sailors sailed pass Egyptian Fauna and palm trees in the Nile delta. The map then follows the river inland and it ends up in a magical city on a kind of river bound island. This mysterious city is surrounded by high walls with multi-storied houses, elegant ladies peering from the rooftops, and a rich harbor. At the time, there was only one port in Egypt that fits the city in the map; the fabled Avaris. Until late in the 20th century there was no archaeological proof of contact between Avaris and the Minoans of Santorini, then in 1992 perfectly preserved Minoan paintings were discovered at Avaris. Proving that in Biblical times this city was not only populated by Israelites but also by people from ancient Greece.”

     Could it be possible that these ancient Greeks followed Moses and the Israelites out of Egypt? The Bible certainly doesn’t give us any information that other people groups came with them on the Exodus. But let us look at the map. Jacobovici claims that these sailors came from the “Fabled Avaris.” He also states that the finding of Minoan artwork at Avaris proves that not only the Israelites populated Avaris, but also the Minoan’s. But as I have stated before, the Israelites dwelt in the land of Goshen (Ex. , ). Also at the time of the map the Israelites were already enslaved under the Egyptians, so how could the Israelites be among the “elegant ladies peering from the rooftops, and a rich harbor?” They were slaves, and obviously slaves would not have dwelt in such a “magical city,” as Jacobovici claims. Isn’t it interesting that this map depicts these Minoan’s coming from Avaris, the Hyksos capital, to Greece? So these Minoan’s could very well have been the Hyksos of Egyptian history, and if this is true the evidence is somewhere out there. Could it be possible to assume that this map depicts the Hyksos expulsion? It was found “when digging under the ash at Santorini,” so could the map be displaying the Hyksos expulsion before the eruption of Santorini; if it was found under the ash of the Santorini volcano. So that would definitely place the Hyksos expulsion before the Exodus, but Jacobovici gives us evidence that Minoans did in fact travel with the Israelites, and saw the parting of the sea. But we know one thing and that was the Minoans and Egyptians did have contact. Dr. Charles Pellegrino states: “Most people do not realize that there is not only contact between the Minoan world and the Egyptians, it was very intense contact; contact in trade, contact in ideas, we have the Egyptians referring to the Minoans as the only other civilization that they considered civilized. It was not a military presence in Egypt it was actually a trade presence.” So we must wonder if these Minoans were the Hyksos, or just another type of people group living within Avaris at the time of the Exodus. Does this place the suspicion back on the Israelites as being the Hyksos though? I would say no, because even though these Minoans might have went with the Israelites there is more speculative proof, with this map, that they are the Hyksos rather then the Israeites.

     One thing that is very clear is that during the time of Moses there’s a great possibility that Minoans were living in Egypt; possibly even through the plagues. Jacobovici claims that “As a result [of finding the map], it’s perfectly reasonable to assume that some of the followers of Moses came from the area of ancient Greece, and it’s quite possible that some of these people returned to Greece after the Exodus.” Jacobovici’s theory can be plausible, and he gives the evidence to back it up. Let us now look at the second piece of evidence Jacobovici gives to support his theory. He states:  “The Bible says that Moses and his followers left Egypt with great quantities of swords and Egyptian gold [Ex. -36]. 3500 years after the fact, is there any chance of finding Israelite swords, and Egypt’s golden treasures in Greece?” In the book of Exodus the way it portrays the Israelites leaving, and gaining the Egyptian treasure, is interesting. Although many people believe they used forceful means to gain the treasure, it is actually by peaceful tactics, although the Bible says that “they spoiled the Egyptians.” But in the Biblical account the Egyptians gave up all their treasures to the Israelites (Ex. -36), because they just wanted them gone; for the Egyptians were afraid they would die. “And the Egyptians were urgent upon the people [The Israelites], that they might send them out of the land in haste; for they said, We be all dead men (Ex. 12:33, KJV).” Surprisingly though, Jacobovici does find the proof he needs from Greece and it come from tombstones that are found in Mycenae, which were discovered by archaeologist Heinrich Schliemann. “The tombs are incredible,” Jacobovici comments, “with long shafts leading to vaulted ceilings; they were built in the shadow of a mountain and has the shape of a pyramid. Surprisingly they contained a treasure trove of swords and Egyptian gold.  Schliemann believed that the gold belonged to Homer’s Agamemnon, who led the war against Troy for the sake of the beautiful Helen, but scholars soon discovered that the people who were buried in the tombs lived about three hundred years before Agamemnon. They lived around 1500 B.C.E.” Jacobovici believes that these tombs are the tombs of the Minoan follower’s of Moses and the Israelites. The answer he seeks is on the tombstones themselves.

     There are three tombstones that stand out to Jacobovici, and he believes they depict the story of the parting of the sea. He takes us through the three steles in a way only a movie director can: “I almost want to whisper, it’s some kind of secret, because nobody realizes that they have a 3500 year old movie issue of three frames of the parting of the sea, and they don’t know it. But look at it, just look at it, it’s so clear! Frame number one you see waves on top and waves on the bottom, you actually literally see the parting of a sea, and this guy is on a chariot chasing Moses whose holding a staff; that’s frame number one, and right over here you have frame number two in the movie. The water is gathering into whirlpools, and look what’s happened over here, everybody thinks the man with the staff is the loser but he’s actually turned around, he’s turned around he’s facing his enemy. He’s occupying higher ground and this guy is occupying lower ground, and look there’s walls of water coming, and in the third frame, which is in another museum, even more hidden. You see this guy’s been overturned, the water is engulfing them, the horses are up-ended, and the story is complete.” Most scholars disagree with Jacobovici’s interpretation of the steles, and he brings in an expert to comment on the stones. Constantinos Paschalidis of the National Archaeological Museum in Athens states: “In this very example the options can be namely two: either, he’s a warrior in a battle scene, and he’s the enemy, he’s chasing the enemy, and the enemy is trying to escape holding this wand, and the second option may be a chariot race scene.” But Jacobovici insists “Here we have literally carved in stone a visual account of the Biblical tale dating back to the very time of Moses and the Exodus.”

     Who could disagree with Jacobovici’s evidence? It is very compelling, and as someone who believes the Biblical account to be historical, I applaud Jacobovici and his attempts to prove the Exodus. We see that the pieces of his puzzle do indeed fit together quite perfectly, although some smoothing out may need to be done. I do feel like Jacobovici put a lot of information into one film and he could have dived deeper into his evidence, giving a more detailed documentary; which of course would’ve required him to do more than one documentary on the Exodus. But all in all the information and evidence he provides is very alluring. At the end of this film I came to realize two things: There is very sound evidence out there to prove the Biblical account of the Exodus. Which also means there is sound evidence out there to prove the rest of the Biblical account. This is why I desire to become a Biblical Archaeologist, to be able to find that proof and like Jacobovici put the pieces of the puzzle, called the Bible, together. Jacobovici ends his documentary with a profound question and I think it is only fit to end this series of post with this quote: “I think we must end our journey as we started with a question: did all this happen as a result of massive geological events triggered by nothing more than nature? Or were the earthquakes, volcano’s, and the tsunami’s caused by divine intervention, when God, decided to free a nation from slavery and forge a new covenant with humanity?”

Monday, June 20, 2011

Putting The Pieces Together Part VI: The Parting of A Sea




I hope my readership has enjoyed the insight and analysis to one of the most asked question; Did the Exodus really happen? In the end we come to realize that science is indeed our friend, if used correctly. Many of the earliest scientists did in fact hold to Christian faith and they believed science backed up their faith, and used it to prove the existence of God. But like with all things, there needs to be a happy medium. I believe Philosophy is the handmaiden of Theology (The study of the Bible), so science should be the same. As Christians we should not throw out science without first looking at it. Science can be used for good unless taken to the extreme. I think our Theology, and what we believe about God and the Bible, should drive our philosophy; and our scientific research. God needs to be the center of our lives as Christians, and once we gain the wisdom of God we can then obtain the wisdom of this world. In this post we will find out if Jacobovici’s scientifc theory of how the parting of the sea occurred will match up with the Biblical record.

     Simcha Jacobovici begins this section, the final events of the Exodus, by saying “But in the book of Exodus God does not spin nature……he manipulates it. In other words according to the Bible we should be able to understand the science behind the miracles, and the greatest miracle of them all was the parting of a sea.” As I have stated before in one of my last posts God did not cause the Santorini volcano to erupt, but He very well could of used, manipulated as Jacobovici states, the effects of it to free His people. The parting of the Red sea is a story that keeps us on the edge of our seats. How did it happen? Many of us wish we could go back in time to see it with our own eyes because it does seem unbelievable. But Jacobovici shows that it can in fact be believable and he strives to scientifically prove that the parting of the sea undeniably happened, and is not just a good story to tell your kids. But will his theories match up with the Biblical text? The Biblical account records that even though Pharaoh let the Israelites go he then pursued them. The Lord told Moses that Pharaoh would pursue them (Exodus 14:3-4). The Biblical account also tells us that Pharaoh took with him all his chariots and officers (Ex. 14:7). The Israelites became trapped by the sea, and in Pharaohs eyes I’m sure he believed he was the victor, but then God showed the Egyptians the power of the God of Israel; for one final time. “After the death of the Egyptian firstborn males Pharaoh let the Israelites go,” Jacobovici comments, “he then changed his mind and pursued them finding them trapped on the shores of a sea. The Hebrew text calls this sea ‘Yam Suf,’ and it was here where the miracle occurred. The sea parted the Israelites crossed to safety and then the water’s came back swallowing the entire Egyptian army, overturned chariots, drowning all the horses and soldiers.”

     For years the translation of the sea Moses parted, “Yam Suf,” has been named the Red sea. Every time the story is told it is always the Red sea that Moses parted. It was not until recently that scholars started seeing that the name “Yam Suf” was mistranslated. Because of this no one has found evidence of the Egyptian armies at the bottom of the Red sea, although there have been many excavations. Jacobovici talks about this misinterpretation: “For years explorers have searched for evidence of the miracle of the parting of the sea. They’ve mounted under water archaeological quests looking for ancient chariots, swords, and any evidence of drowned Egyptian armies. There is a theory that a huge sub-surface shelf in the Red sea could’ve been exposed for a short time during a powerful storm, providing a land-bridge for the Israelites to cross. But the search has always been unsuccessful. Who would’ve thought that instead of diving we should’ve been driving? That’s because ‘Yam Suf,’ Hebrew for the place where Moses had parted the waters, has for years been mistranslated as ‘red sea,’ when in fact the correct translation is ‘reed sea,’ and reeds grow in sweet water, not salt water; in lakes not oceans.” So his theory is that the sea was a lake, but finding the body of water the Bible describes is hard. The Biblical account calls it a sea, and the Israelites complained to Moses because they thought they were going to die, because of Pharaoh (Ex. -12). The Lord did not only show His power to the Egyptians but also to the children of Israel, Who saw all the plagues of Egypt and the parting of the sea, but they still complained constantly and because of their unbelief they did not get to see the Promised land, and died out in the wilderness.

Again Jacobovici comes through with the evidence to prove his theories. “Using our dates for the Exodus, we’ve tracked down an ancient artifact that records the precise location of ‘Yam Suf.’ It also provides us with the first archaeological evidence for the parting of the sea.” The artifact he refers to is the Elarish Inscription which can be found in the Ismailia Regional Museum. “We found a hieroglyphic inscription on a granite monument that tells the entire story of the Exodus from Pharaoh’s point of view.” Jacobovici explains the Elarish Inscription, and compares it with the Bible. “The Bible calls Moses a king, on this stone Moses is called ‘The Prince of the desert.’ The Bible calls the Israelites ‘God’s people,’ the granite calls them ‘the evil ones,’ and then the granite corroborates the miracle of the parting of the sea. The symbol can be read by anyone, three waves and two knives ‘the parted sea.’” Professor James Hoffmeier from Trinity Evangelical School gives his opinion on the inscription: “The three water signs one on top of the other, is typically used to apply to different types of bodies of water, can apply to the Nile, can apply to a marsh, can apply to the sea. But what is not so common is when you have that word in combination with these two knives. The fact you have these two knives associated with it would suggest that this is water that is cut, water that is divided. This might be an illusion to the waters that the red sea, or the reed sea, were divided in Exodus chapter fourteen.” Jacobovici believes the place that the parting of the sea happened was at the modern lake named El Balah. Professor Hoffmeier continues in saying “It’s an ancient lake that survived until the 1850’s, when the Suez canal was put in this ancient lake finally died. Professor Manifred Bietak, after conducting further study of this area, proposed that this lake was known to the Egyptians as ‘Pa Tufi,’ the marsh land, the marshy sea, and the word ‘Tuf,’ Egyptian word for reeds, is the same word as ‘Suf’ in Hebrew, so the ‘Yam Suf ‘ he suggested was a name derived from this body of water. Now it’s called the El Balah lake.”

     Jacobovici has, what he believes, the sea Moses parted, he has his evidence from the Elarish inscription to prove El Balah is the correct lake. Next, he will give us his theory on how the Israelites crossed over the sea on dry land, and how the watr swallowed up the Egyptians. “As Pharaoh chased the Israelites to the shores of lake El Balah, the extreme seismic activity that caused the ten plagues, and the Santorini eruption, would’ve now caused the delta to start sliding into the eastern Mediterranean, and as millions tons of soil moved forward the edge of the African plate, which had now been released from its burden, must have risen between one, and one and a half meters. In other words the sea parted. Water would have cascaded from higher ground to lower ground and drained from pools and sink holes creating dry land for the Israelites to cross. At this point, further seismic activity, or another collapse of the delta, would’ve sent a major tsunami crashing against the coast.” Dr. Charles Pellegrino comments on the height of the waves that would’ve been the tsunami in Jacobovici’s theory: “They would to have been more than half as high, these waves, as the Empire State Building, and that’s exactly the description that we do have in the Bible.” This tsunami would be the same one depicted in the Bible that came crashing down on the Egyptians. But let us see what the Biblical text says and see if it can match up with Jacobovici’s theory.

The Bible states: “And Moses stretched out his hand over the sea; and the Lord caused the sea to go back by a strong east wind all that night, and made the sea dry land, and the waters were divided. And the children of Israel went into the midst of the sea upon the dry ground: and the waters were a wall unto them on their right hand, and on their left (Exodus -22, KJV).” This doesn’t quite match up with Jacobovici’s theory that water was drained by sink holes, because the Bible clearly states that an east wind literally parted the sea so that there was a wall on each side of the Israelites as they passed on dry land. Jacobovici doesn’t go into this and the question I’d ask would be: how does your theory fit with the Biblical record? We see that his theory about how the sea was parted doesn’t match the Bible, but what about his tsunami theory? Does that fit with the Bible? Let us continue with the Biblical account. Exodus chapter fourteen, verses twenty-three through twenty-five states: “And the Egyptians pursued, and went in after them to the midst of the sea, even all Pharaoh’s horses, his chariots, and his horsemen. And it came to pass, that in the morning watch the Lord looked unto the host of the Egyptians through the pillar of fire and of the cloud, and troubled the host of the Egyptians, And took off their chariot wheels, that they drive them heavily: so that the Egyptians said, let us flee from the face of Israel; for the Lord fights for them against the Egyptians (KJV).” A tsunami might have crashed doen on the Egyptians but what oter evidenc does Jacobovici gives us? This is an interesting part in the Biblical account. The Egyptians are kept away from pursuing the Israelites until the dawn of the next day, which means that the Israelites had to have crossed on the dry land all through the night. In Jacobovici’s theory he gives the impression that the tsunami came on faster than the Biblical account records, so it still doesn't match up. The thing that gets me about this passage is verse twenty-four, for if I was an Egyptian and saw the face of God I’d want to high-tale it out of there as well. It’s also intriguing that the Egyptians know the Lord is fighting with Israel against them. They knew who God was and what side He was on. Let us continue, “And Moses stretched forth his hand over the sea, and the sea returned to his strength when the morning appeared; and the Egyptians fled against it; and the Lord overthrew the Egyptians in the midst of the sea. And the waters returned, and covered the chariots, and the horsemen, and all the host of Pharaoh that came into the sea after them; there remained not so much as one of them (Ex. -28, KJV).” There is no similarity between Jacobovici’s theory and the Biblical account, and he may have to do more study and research on this. But this does not mean that the effects of the Santorini eruption wasn’t used by God to cause the sea to part. In my next post Jacobovici will bring up some evidence that proves the sea was parted and that the Biblical account is true; even though he can't correctly prove how it happened doesn't mean it didn't happen at all. There are two questions we must ask: How can a story, like the Biblical account, be fake if it so detailed? And, are there some things that science just can’t explain?

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Putting The Pieces Together Part V: Is Science A Friend or Foe Part III; Can The Death of The Firstborn Free The Israelites of The Conviction That They’re The Hyksos?



This is the final plague of Egypt; the death of the firstborn, man and animal. Many who hold to a Christian faith would say that it is impossible to scientifically prove this last plague, for it was God himself who came down to carry out the tenth plague. But Simcha Jacobovici is certain he can scientifically prove this plague and gives us his theory on it. But he doesn’t just have a theory; he has evidence to back up his theory. Evidence that was found in the Hyksos capital, Avaris. The evidence from Avaris brings us back to the question of whether the Israelites and Hyksos are the same in one. I will go over my own theory on this.  

Despite the first nine plagues and their destruction on the land of Egypt, Pharaoh would not let the Israelites go. In the Biblical account Pharaoh is depicted as somewhat of a deceiver. He answered “No” to Moses and Aaron all ten times and his answer resulted in a plague coming down upon him and his people, and when the plague became too much Pharaoh informed them he would let them go if God would stop the plague. Which God did, but then Pharaoh took it back and never let them go. From this effect came the cause of another plague upon Pharaoh’s land. This act of defiance proceeded through all nine plagues, but when the result of the tenth plague was completed Pharaoh finally gave in, for his son had died, and he let the Israelites go. “The final plague took place at ,” Jacobovici explains, “after Moses ordered the Israelites to sit down to what became known as the first Passover meal. While the Israelites were involved in the Passover ritual the Egyptians slept, and then it happened. Every firstborn male Egyptian died. Every house was affected. No one has ever been able to offer a plausible scientific explanation for the death of the firstborn; until now.”

Will Jacobovici’s scientific theory for the death of the firstborn get rid of the Biblical story? Because it was the Lord himself who came down and smote all firstborn males. Or can his theory work alongside the text, having God manipulate the effects of the Santorini eruption using it for his purpose? Jacobovici’s theory is that “The gas leak that set the chain of plagues in motion would’ve finally erupted. Carbon-dioxide would’ve seeped to the surface and being heavier than air would’ve killed animals and sleeping people before it dissipated harmlessly into the atmosphere.” But, like with all of Jacobovici’s pieces, this is often disputed but he persists in proving his claims and continues by saying “In case you think all this is conjecture. Consider this, it happened in exactly the same way in 1986 at Lake Nyos, Cameroon.” He then goes on to describe the events that occurred on Lake Nyos. “As the people of Lake Nyos slept, the top of the lake was keeping the carbon down like a cap on a pop bottle. But then, the earth rumbled and a landslide took place sending rock into the water, disturbing the surface pressure and releasing the gas. The gas then rose to the surface and like some alien monster emerged from the water, droplets forming on it, turning the invisible gas into a visible fog. The fog then rolled across the water and across the land, suffocating everything in its path, and then suddenly as it appeared……it disappeared, dissolving harmlessly into the atmosphere.” This is the scientific theory behind plague number ten, but can the Biblical account and the scientific theory fit together? Jacobovici believes so.

What was it that in the end made the defiant Pharaoh cave in and surrender to the Lord God of the Israelites? He clearly saw that the God of Israel was the true God but yet still hardened his heart. The Lord knew that Pharaoh would always say ‘no’ in response to Moses and would defy Him, and this is clearly seen through the biblical account throughout the first fourteen chapters in the book of Exodus. Also, again, the Israelites are kept safe from this plague, and Moses tells Pharaoh the words of the Lord: “But against any of the children of Israel shall not a dog move his tongue, against man or beast: that you may know how that the Lord doth put a difference between the Egyptians and Israel (Ex. 11:7, KJV).” Jacobovici goes on to say that “It was this selectivity that demonstrated to him God himself was involved. How can we account for this? Well, Egyptian firstborn males had a privileged position; they were the heirs to throne, to property, to title, to more. They slept on Egyptian beds low to the ground, while their brothers and sisters slept on rooftops, sheds, and in wagons. The Israelites sitting up at their first Passover meal did not feel a thing, while the low traveling gas suffocated the privileged position males sleeping in their beds.”           

     In Jacobovici’s persistence to prove his theories, once again he offers compelling evidence to back them up. This time his evidence comes from an archaeological standpoint. He takes us back to the city of Avaris for the evidence: “This conclusion is backed by the archaeology. In Avaris Professor Manifred Bietak has found mass graves dating to before and during our date for the Exodus. The earlier graves are classic examples of ancient epidemics that killed men, women, and children. But at the time of the Exodus the mass grave he found has only males in it.” Professor Bietak quotes: “Here you see bones of burials from the early eighteenth Dynasty, they’re all male victims, and the size of the graves, and the amount of the individuals in the graves we think people died in rapid succession, and the individuals were just thrown into the pit; some of them lying on their stomachs, some lying on their side, some of the pits were just twenty centimeters deep and just some dust put on top of them.” In the end of my post I will give my theory on these mass graves that are found at Avaris, and we will see if the Hyksos can be connected to Israelites. The graves found at Avaris seem to back up, undoubtingly, the death of the firstborn. Although more than a few scholars, scientists, and archaeologist will disagree with Jacobovici’s findings. But Jacobovici doesn’t stop here, even though this is very convincing evidence, he continues to persist to find every little detail he can to prove the Exodus really happened. “The Bible says that Pharaoh’s son also died during the plague of the firstborn. Since we claim that Ahmose is the Pharaoh of the Exodus, we should be able to prove that Ahmose’s son died young.” Surprisingly Jacobovici comes through with the evidence once again, and shows that Pharaoh Ahmose did indeed have a son, Prince Sapair, and he did indeed die at a young age. Jacobovici comments: “Searching in the Cairo museum we found Ahmose’s son, the Prince had died young; he was only twelve. For the first time ever we can put a face and a name to a victim of the Biblical plagues.”  
 
     Here I will deal with my theory on the mass graves found in the Hyksos capital city, Avaris. If indeed these are the victims of the tenth plague of Egypt, the death of the firstborn, then this cancels out the suspicion that the Hyksos and Israelites are the same in one. Why? Because, through all the plagues that were unleashed on Egypt the Israelites were not affected. In the book of Exodus chapter twelve, verse twenty-seven Moses tells the Israelites: “That you shall say. It is the sacrifice of the Lord’s Passover, who passed over the houses of the children of Israel in Egypt, when he smote the Egyptians, and delivered our houses. And the people bowed the head and worshipped (KJV).” The tenth plague was different from the rest because of the fact that the Israelites had to spread the blood of a lamb over their doorposts (Ex. 12:1-28). Through all of the nine plagues the Israelites were kept safe but for the tenth plague they had to carry out a condition, spreading lamb’s blood on the doorposts (Ex. 12:7), to be saved from death. If the Israelites didn’t do this they would have met the same fate as the Egyptians. So if the graves at Avaris prove the tenth plague then that frees the Israelites from being the Hyksos. First, because it proves the land that Avaris sits on is a completely different land from Goshen, which Goshen is where the Israelites dwelt (Ex. , ). This then proves that the Israelites were not the Hyksos, for if they were wouldn’t they have been in Avaris? So the Hyksos and Israelites are not one in the same. Lastly, the Hyksos had to have been expelled from Egypt either before or after the Israelite Exodus, because Avaris was affected by the plagues (according to Jacobovici). Ahmose is the Pharaoh Jacobovici uses as the Pharaoh who wouldn’t let the Israelites go, and one thing that all scholars agree on is that he’s famous for the Hyksos expulsion. So because of this we can presume the Hyksos were expelled some time before the plagues battered the once prosperous Egypt. This then brings up another question: are those graves marked as just males, plague victims or victims of war? For there is only two reasons people would be dishonorably buried in mass graves holding numerous victims, and that is either in an epidemic or in battle. So this is the question we must ask, and hopefully I will study and research more about the Hyksos and their rule and their expulsion. But one thing is for certain. From Jacobovici’s mass graves we thwart all suggestions that claim the Hyksos and Israelites as the same people group
    
Can one truly argue with Jacobovici’s evidence? His pieces still continue to look as though they fit perfectly within the puzzle. Jacobovici’s theories and evidence is not only controversial with the scholars, scientists, and archaeologist but also on the other side of the spectrum, Christians who claim the Exodus story as truth. James Cameron ends this section of the documentary, dealing with the plagues of Egypt, and comments: “It seems that the Bible, geology, and archaeology are all telling the same story. The skeptics who would like to regard the Exodus as myth might resist the idea that it actually happened, because this would apply that God does indeed exist. Believer’s on the other hand may feel the scientific explanation of the Biblical story takes God out of the equation.” So Jacobovici is cornered by both sides, and both sides are skeptical about his information all together. But with the evidence he presents how can one argue with him? Some of the facts may be misrepresented and his dating, to most scholars, is off scale. But only time will prove if Simcha Jacobovici’s pieces truly fit to make up the puzzle of the Exodus. Jacobovici gave us his theories along with the facts to back it up, so only time and more research will prove if his chronology is indeed right; and the Exodus is indeed history. Which is my belief, but further research and study needs to be done to get the kinks out of Jacobovici’s puzzle.

Putting The Pieces Together Part IV: Is Science A Friend or Foe Part II; Dealing With the Last Plagues of Egypt



Continuing from my last post we will be looking at the last plagues Egypt experienced during the Exodus story in the Bible. Simcha Jacobovici still claims he can scientifically prove these plagues, even the tenth plague which is the death of all the firstborn. Jacobovici is confident that he can explain all the plagues as being the effects of the Santorini eruption, and gives tantalizing evidence for his claim. We will be looking at each plague individually and viewing Jacobovici’s scientific evidence for them, and we will also be analyzing these plagues from a Biblical viewpoint. The Santorini eruption is still Jacobovici’s center piece for the plagues, and the parting of the Red sea. But can science really illuminate for us all the miracles God used to free His people? Does Jacobovici take it too far, or is his evidence sound? These are the questions we must ask ourselves through Jacobovici’s documentary, many scholars, archaeologists, Theologians, and Scientists will stand against Jacobovici’s claims. They would argue that his dates are distorted and twisted, and his evidence is inclusive and fragmented. But what if Jacobovici’s scientific explanations and dates are closer to the truth than we realize?

“Plague six is boils and blisters, man and beast [Ex. 9:8-12]. Can an earthquake induced gas leak explain this kind of outbreak?” The answer to Jacobovici’s question is yes, and to prove it he goes back to Lake Nyos. “People living along the lake developed strange boils and burns. It turns out that carbon-dioxide mixed with air put people into a kind of a coma, reducing circulation to the skin causing the kind of boils described in the Bible as plague number six.” Was carbon-dioxide really the cause of the Biblical boils? What about in the book of Exodus where the Lord tells Moses to pick up ash from the furnace and that becomes dust which is let it go into the air, from this the boils come over the Egyptians both men and animals. Did the boils in the Biblical account come from the ash or from Jacobovici’s carbon-dioxide? His claim is plausible, but one fact that cannot be scientifically explained is that throughout all the plagues, even though the Egyptians were affected, the Israelites were kept safe (Ex. 8:22-23, 9:4-7, 9:25-26, 10:23, 11:7, 12:13). The ten plagues that occurred in Egypt did not happen in the land of the Israelites, a place called Goshen. This is what the Bible records, for the Lord not only showed His power through the plagues, but also through protecting His people from the plagues.

The seventh plague was a unique one, and I’m sure the people living during that time believed the God of Israel to be the only true God because of such a plague. The Biblical account tells us that Moses and Aaron, repeating the words of the Lord, gave Pharaoh a chance to take his people and cattle out of harms way (Ex. -20). For the seventh plague was hail and fire raining down on Egypt. Rabbi Chaim Sacknovitz gives a description of the hail Egypt experienced: “The seventh plague was a plague of hail, but the Bible describes hail in a very unique manner. That hail was together with ‘esh,’ fire. The idea being that the fire and ice commingled together, they co-existed together. The Bible then describes God is making a miracle within a miracle, taking opposites in nature and having them co-exist together.” But Pharaoh didn’t heed the warning and his servants and herds were killed in the fields, (Ex. -26). Can Jacobovici scientifically prove this particular epidemic? His answer would be “yes.” He gets Dr. Catherine Hickson to explain the science behind plague number seven: “When the ash cloud goes up to great distances in the stratosphere, essentially what happens is you have moisture in the atmosphere, you also have a lot of water vapor in the cloud itself so the small fragments of ash and crystals come to form a nucleus; something very similar to a hail storm.” “In other words,” Jacobovici continues, “Egypt experienced fire and ice raining from above just as the Bible describes. It seems that earthquakes and the resulting volcanic and gas eruptions neatly explain the first seven Biblical plagues.” Jacobovici believes that the context of a famous papyrus, The Ipuwar Papyrus, which gives an account of a hail storm that was mixed with fire, is the same hail storm as the Biblical account. But, like with all of Jacobovici’s pieces to the Exodus puzzle, many scholars argue that his chronology for the Ipuwar Papyrus is unconvincing. Jacobovici illustrates for us how the context of the Ipuwar Papyrus matches closely to the Biblical record: “Incredibly there is an Egyptian Papyrus that tells the exact same story, it’s called the Ipuwar Papyrus and it’s dated by many scholars to the Hyksos period. The Ipuwar Papyrus specifically states that Egypt was struck by a strange hail made up of ice and fire mingled together. Another piece of the puzzle has fallen in place, it now seems clear that the Biblical and Egyptian texts are describing what scientists call……volcanic hail, that could only have come from the earthquake induced Santorini volcano.” Dr. Catherine Hickson gave an example of this type of hail and the science seems to back Jacobovici’s claim. But the date for the Ipuwar Papyrus is often controversial.

The eighth plague is Locusts. The Biblical text records something interesting that I wish to bring up before we get into Jacobovici’s scientific explanations. When Moses and Aaron come to Pharaoh after the seventh plague and after he, once again, tells them he’ll let them go then takes it back when the Lord clears away the hail storm. Pharaoh’s servants say something very interesting: “And Pharaoh’s servants said to him, how long shall this man be a snare to us? Let the men go, that they may serve the Lord their God: do you not know that Egypt is destroyed (Ex. 10:7, KJV)?” Pharaoh’s servants are basically begging him to send away the Israelites because the plagues have destroyed the Egypt they once knew, worked in, and lived in. All the people of Egypt, whether they would admit it or not, knew that the true god was the God of the Israelites, for they had probably prayed constantly to their gods for protection; but the gods of Egypt could not save them from the plagues. This text about the servants gives us a little insight into the thoughts of the Egyptian people during that time. From this small passage we can see that the Egyptians wished for Pharaoh to let the Israelites go, so that they wouldn’t have to suffer anymore for their ruler’s malevolence. Also we see that they realize the God of the Israelites is only true God, because the servants call Him “The Lord their God,” which indicates they know the name of the God of the Israelites. Now we will look at Jacobovici’s scientific explanation of the eighth plague, locusts. Jacobovici asserts that “Locust migrate in swarms that can be between forty and eighty million adult locust in each square kilometer. Cold weather produces a drop in their body temperature and makes them land on mass. The volcanic hail and the weather disruption caused by the Santorini eruption would’ve forced great clouds of locust, which are common in this part of the world, to suddenly land in Egypt. As the hail storm cleared and the temperature rose, so did the locust; exactly as the Biblical account describes.”

Jacobovici begins the introduction of the second to last plague with this statement: “Ripped by earthquake storms and their consequences the Egyptians were now going to experience the last phase of the Santorini eruption, or what the Bible calls plague number nine; darkness.” In the Biblical account the darkness lasted for three days and, like with all the plagues, it only affected the land of the Egyptians; the Israelites were unaffected by it. In Exodus chapter 10 verse 23 it says “…but all the children of Israel had light in their dwellings (KJV).” Jacobovici has a theory for explaining this plague, but many scholars will disagree with it and claim it as a controversial subject. “This is the way it probably worked, during the months before the eruption seismic activity in the whole Eastern Mediterranean was causing the African plate to grind under the European plate. Sea water was then turned to steam that bubbled up through the magma. This in turn caused pressure to build and erupt through weak points in the surface, triggering several small eruptions, leading to a major blow-out. When the final eruption came it created an ash cloud, almost 40 kilometers from top to bottom and 200 kilometers across. When the ash cloud reached the Nile Delta it engulfed the Egyptians in what the Bible calls a palpable darkness.” Dr. Catherine Hickson continues this thought by stating: “In a matter of a few minutes their plunged into a black world, ashes falling all around them, they can’t see, they can’t breath very well, the sun has disappeared, you have black overhead, and they have no idea what’s going to happen next.”

The volcanic rock (pumice) that was found in Avaris by Dr. Manifred Bietak seems to be proof enough that the Santorini eruption is the cause of the plagues. But this is under much controversy and Jacobovici claims that “Some might argue that since pumice can float, it could’ve been brought to Egypt by waves, and washed ashore by tides.” But Jacobovici is persistent in finding the evidence he needs to prove that the ten plagues of Egypt, the Red sea parting, and the Exodus in general is a true story, and that it is all centered on the natural disaster known as the Santorini eruption. How can anyone argue with his next piece of evidence? The finding of Santorini ash in Egypt. Although, many would say, this only proves the eruption of Santorini not the Exodus or the plagues. Prof. Jean-Daniel Stanley comments that: “We had to look through ten to twenty thousand grains to find one ash grain, so we found a total of forty ash grains. Not all ash looks the same, ash has a fingerprint aspect. The ash particles that we find in the northern and north eastern Nile Delta are individual grains that came in from Santorini.” I will need to stop here at the ninth plague because I hadn’t realized how long this section would be. But to stop here gives my readership a good place to stop, where they won’t have to read ten pages, as well as leaves them in suspense. Jacobovici’s evidence just seems to fit perfectly with his puzzle, but could it be too perfectly? In the final plague I will deal with Jacobovici’s evidence and theories as well as some theories of my own.

Saturday, June 11, 2011

Putting The Pieces Together Part III: Is Science A Friend or Foe Part I; Can God Use A Natural Disaster for His Glory?






There are three things that come to mind when mentioning the Exodus: the ten plagues of Egypt, the parting of the Red sea, and the Ten Commandments. As Christians who are taught this story in Sunday school we tend to grow up just simply believing these miracles on a “blind faith” scale. But what if science “could” be used to explain these miracles? Would that be bumping God out of the picture entirely? Or would it magnify the evidence of His existence? Simcha Jacobovici claims he can scientifically prove the ten plagues of Egypt and the parting of the Red sea, and it’s all centered around one natural disaster; the eruption of a volcano on the Mediterranean coast. This natural disaster wiped out one nation of people to free another nation of people from slavery.

Jacobovici leads us to first look at the Santorini eruption for it may hold the secret to the miracles that occurred in the book of Exodus. All the other pieces in Jacobovici’s puzzle all date to around 1500 B.C.E. He states that “If our date is correct then there’s something else we have to factor in, around 1500 B.C.E. people living on the Mediterranean experienced one of the most cataclysmic events in history. The eruption of the Santorini volcano in modern Greece.” He continues by declaring that “When it erupted it the volcano essentially brought to an end the Minoan Civilization that once flourished here.” The eruption was so great that it not only affected the explosion area but the surrounding areas as well, such as Egypt. Dr Catherine Hickson gives us a profound statement for how immense the eruption really was, and what is was like for those living there at the time. “To put this in perspective, an eruption like Santorini would be hundreds to thousands of times stronger, more explosive, then the atom bomb that was dropped on Hiroshima……and it would have been, I’m sure to the people living there, as if the world was coming to and end.”  Jacobovici is claiming that the Santorini eruption is the cause for all of the phenomenon’s surrounding the Exodus. But one thing is uncertain, and that’s the date for the Santorini eruption, but Jacobovici is convinced that the Santorini eruption fits within his chronology. Dr. Manifred Bietak, founder of the Hyksos capital Avaris, states: “Here pumice [Volcanic rock] from the Santorini eruption appears for the first time. So from an archaeological point of view it looks very much as if the eruption happened early in the 18th dynasty, let us say around 1500 B.C.E.” Jacobovici is very persistent on making his claim that the eruption occurred in this time frame, but like all things that deal with the Exodus this date is disputed. Dr. Charles Pellegrino asserts that “Volcanologists and geologists would date the eruption in the 1600’s B.C. Archaeologists tend to date it in the 1500’s B.C.” Because these dates are so widely disputed many scholars would argue that Jacobovici is stretching, because of his pre-conceived notions, to place all these events in the same time frame. But could Jacobovici be on to something? Do all these pieces fit correctly into the puzzle? Could a natural disaster, which is claimed as one of the worst volcanic eruptions in history, be the cause of the ten plagues and the Red sea parting?

Jacobovici certainly believes so, and he also claims that “Until now, no one has come up with a comprehensive scientific explanation for all ten plagues.” He then takes us back to the first puzzle piece, the Ahmose Stele, which seems to have “an amazing synchronicity with the Bible text.” Comparing the Stele to the Biblical text Jacobovici explains: “The Bible says that the God of Israel passed judgment on the gods of Egypt, and the Stele confirms that the statues of the gods of Egypt were toppled to the ground.” The verse used here in this comparison is Exodus 12:12, which says “For I [God] will pass through the land of Egypt this night, and will smite all the firstborn in the land of Egypt, both man and beast; and against all the gods of Egypt I will execute judgment: I am the Lord(NKJV).” It truly is amazing how the Ahmose Stele and the Biblical text record such synchronicity, not only once but twice. The Ahmose Stele could very well be recording events that occurred from the Santorini eruption, and could very well be the same events that the Biblical author recorded. What if this Archaeological artifact proves the Biblical text to be accurate? He goes on to say that “Earthquakes are known to accompany volcanic eruptions like Santorini. It seems that the Stele and the Bible are describing the results of an earthquake, or more precisely what scientists now call an earthquake storm.” “Earthquake storms,” Prof. Amos Nur of Stanford University states, “are sequences of large earthquakes that sweep across a large area, and the best examples are the Eastern Mediterranean, where we have long historical and archaeological records.” But can such earthquakes cause the ten plagues of Egypt to occur?

Jacobovici certainly thinks so: “Earthquakes can’t possibly explain how Moses turned the Nile water’s into blood, can they? In fact they can. When they trigger gas leaks, and we don’t have to go back 3500 years to prove the point.” He gives the example of lake Nyos, Cameroon, when the waters in the lake turned red like in the Biblical tale. Professor George Kling was the scientist who explained the mystery as an under-water gas leak, and the same thing could very well have happened with the Biblical story. Professor George Kling states: “When it comes to the Biblical plagues along the Nile delta there, there are many elements that are present that could suggest a build up of gas, so we could have a situation where gas beneath the earth is trapped in pockets and earthquakes along the fault-line then release that gas and depending on the kind of water that that gas goes through it could even turn that water red.” Jacobovici continues on this thought “The first thing that happens in such circumstances is that the water becomes devoid of oxygen, and all living things in it die……the only things that don’t die are frogs, unlike fish they can hop out, and as it turns out Biblical plague number two is a frog infestation [Ex. 8:3]. The lack of clean water then leads to lice, flies, and bacterial epidemics among humans and domestic animals, not surprisingly Biblical plague three is lice [Ex. 8:16], plague number four is flies [Ex. 8:21], plague number five is an epidemic [Ex. 9:3-4].”

These are just the first five plagues, but in my next post I will continue to go over Simcha Jacobovici’s scientific explanations of the next five plagues. We see in this post that Jacobovici could really be on to something, many scholars would disagree with me, but the pieces of his puzzle seem to be fitting perfectly. So I come back to my question. Could science be used to prove the ten plagues of Egypt? From the evidence just presented I would say it is plausible. But then comes another question. Where does God fit in? I believe that God fits perfectly within the picture, even when using science. In the book of Exodus God first speaks to Moses before any of the plagues, or the parting of the Red sea, actually occur (Exodus chapters 7 through 14). So clearly these events didn’t take God by surprise, He foreknew they would happen in His omniscience, and all He expected from Moses was faith and obedience. Even though some of these miracles can be explained scientifically, not all of them can, and are still looked at as unexplainable miracles. Such as the burning bush encounter (Ex. 3:2), and the staff that turned into a serpent (Ex. ). Science should always be looked at as a tool to bring out truth with hard facts, and because God is truth therefore science cannot be bad……if it is used in the right manner. But then if the plagues were caused because of one of the greatest natural disasters in history, then does that mean that God is responsible for destroying one society of people to free another? The answer to this is a resounding “No.” Some Christians might say that God caused the Santorini eruption to happen for the “greater good” of Israel being freed from Egypt. But that is incorrect. First, as we have seen in the book of Exodus God is omniscient, and so because He foresaw and knew that Santorini’s volcano was to erupt doesn’t mean God caused it to happen, (many scholars, as I have said, will not agree with Jacobovici on the eruption being at the same time of the Exodus, and would claim I am just making speculations. Just to let my readership know, so that they can make their own analysis on these posts). Sometimes nature does what it does, not because God caused or forced it to happen, but because of what happened back in Genesis. When man sinned it not only affected men and animals, but nature as well. In the book of Romans chapter eight, the Apostle Paul talks about the affect sin has upon nature “For we know that the whole creation groaneth and travaileth in pain together until now (v. 22, NKJV). Lastly, God does not desire the destruction of anyone (2 Peter 3:9), so why would He cause a natural disaster to annihilate an entire civilization? “Oh, I got it, because they were wicked.” But God doesn’t desire that “any” should perish, this would include the wicked along with the good. Why did He send Jonah to Nineveh so that they could be warned of the coming destruction and were given the opportunity to repent, if he wished them all to die? So clearly God did not kill off one civilization to save His people. In His foreknowledge He could have seen the affects of the eruption and then therefore brought good out of a horrific situation, a situation caused by the effects of sin in the world not by His own hand. Sometimes nature reacts the way it does because it is groaning, and it’s on a downward spiral because it will eventually come to an end, as the book of Revelations states. But the good news is that it will be renewed and reformed into the New Earth, and so it will once again be in its perfect state as it was before sin entered into it.

Tuesday, June 7, 2011

Putting The Pieces Together Part II: The Israelites, slaves or kings?




As we saw in my last post, Simcha Jacobovici, film director and producer, has been on the search to find evidence for one of the greatest stories ever told; the Exodus. This next piece of Jacobovici’s puzzle is often disputed. It is the claim that the Israelites are a people the Egyptians call the Hyksos. The name in Hieroglyphics is Hykussos, which means “foreign rulers.” You have scholars who agree and disagree that the Hyksos and the Israelites are one in the same. The evidence that Jacobovici reveals is very compelling, and he gives hints that he agrees with this claim but his real thoughts on the matter are concealed. In this post I won’t deal too much with my thoughts on this argument, but I will write my hypothesis of the Hyksos and the Israelites in an upcoming post--- Because this claim made about the Hyksos and Israelites being the same group of people is just that: a hypothesis, speculation.

Jacobovici starts this section of his video with explaining as much as he can about a group of people that once ruled Lower Egypt, which the Egyptians called the Hyksos. There’s not a lot to know about the Hyksos, but since the discovery of their capital city, Avaris, I’m sure that will change and a great deal of information about these ancient people will be found. Jacobovici remarks that “Egyptian history clearly states that the Hyksos, who ruled mighty Avaris, were Semites like the Israelites and that they left on a mass exodus known as the ‘Hyksos expulsion.’” He goes on to say “If the Hyksos expulsion and the Biblical Exodus are really one in the same event, then perhaps we can find the long sought after proof for the Biblical Exodus during the Hyksos period.” A famous author, Dr. Charles Pellegrino, agrees with Jacobovici that the Hyksos expulsion and the Biblical account are the same event, and the same people group. Dr. Pellegrino states: “We have in the Bible the story of the Semites leaving Egypt and going eastward from Egypt. At the same time, independent of the Bible, we have a story of the Hyksos being expelled from Egypt. I think definitely the two stories are related. They’re describing the same event from different view points.” Scholars have different analyses on this issue and Jacobovici shows us this in his documentary: “But most scholars say that the Hyksos and the Israelites cannot be equated, because the Hyksos left Egypt hundreds of years before Moses was born.” Because of the conflict between the Hyksos and the Israelite enigma, the date of the Exodus has been moved around quite a bit, but Jacobovici explains that many scholars believe that “The Chronology of ancient Egypt cannot be tampered with.” One of these scholars is Professor William Dever from the University of Arizona: “You can play with Egyptian dates, you can move them up maybe ten years and down ten years, but you can’t move them up or down fifty or a hundred years. That’s not possible, and yet many people try to do that, they try to adjust chronology to fit their pre-determined notion of Biblical history. You can’t do it.” Jacobovici responds to Dever’s report with a single sentence “But maybe we have to.” Then he goes on to say, “What if scholars are placing the Exodus in the wrong time period? Imagine the confusion if in the future scholars date World War II to the 1990’s.” Many scholars date the Exodus at 1270 B.C.E. but, as we can clearly see, Jacobovici’s goal is to place the Exodus in the Hyksos period, 1500 B.C.E. To reach this goal he introduces a scholar who gives a similar date to his. Professor John Bimson states: “The Bible gives information that would put the Exodus about four hundred and eighty years before the early years of Solomon in the middle of the 15th century B.C.” Jacobovici replies by saying Bimson’s “Calculations move the Exodus from its present date to 1470 B.C.E. Less than hundred years from the traditional date for the Hyksos expulsion.” From Bimson’s date Jacobovici is now able to place the Exodus at the date he believes is best suitable. “These [The dates] are too close to write off as a coincidence, so we have a new date for the Exodus; approximately 1500 B.C.E.”

This is where I will put my input. I agree with Jacobovici on his dating the Exodus around 1500 B.C.E., because of the Ahmose Stele, and the eruption of the Santorini volcano (which we will get into in my next post). But what I do not agree with is Jacobovici’s attempt to place the Hyksos and the Israelites as the same people in one, and to set the Hyksos expulsion and the Exodus as the same event. Placing the Hyksos and the Israelites as the same people cannot be possible. Dr. Charles Pellegrino stated that the Hyksos expulsion and the Exodus were similar stories, but just because they are similar does not make them the same story. Similarity does not equal equivalency; to be like something is not to be that thing. To be like God does not mean that you are God. In the garden of Eden Adam and Eve didn’t seek after being like God, for they were already made in his likeness, they sought after His God-hood; they sought to be God. So the Israelites may look similar to the Hyksos, but that doesn’t mean they were the people that once ruled Lower Egypt (I will deal more of this in an upcoming post).

Here I would like to go over a few points that I believe we need to look at before assuming that the Hyksos and Israelites are the same in one, for to do that is to get rid of the biblical account completely. First, Jacobovici just compared Ahmose’s Stele to the biblical account, and because both claim that the storm and darkness occurred then the Biblical author is expounding truth. (On a side note I wish to interject that when the Ahmose Stele says that “The storm and the darkness happened when [G]od, in the singular, manifested his power.” Well that just goes to prove God means what he says. For all throughout the book of Exodus (7:5, 7:17, 8:22, these are just a few verses), God tells Moses that He will show Egypt His power so they will know that He is God). Second, if you take the Biblical account of the storm and darkness to be true, you must take the rest of the account to be true. You can’t pick and choose what is true and what is false, if some of it is true then you must look on the whole as truth. What if we picked and chose truth and falsities with our history books today, like with the Holocaust? We would say something like this: “The Nazi’s were in Germany and under Hitler, but they didn’t do anything harmful; they were humanitarian.” Imagine the absurdity, but because it’s the Biblical text and it’s a religious text it’s okay to pick and choose what we think is truthful and what we think is falsity, right? No, to do this is not alright. So when the Bible mentions the Israelites as slaves, more than once, and has no recoding of them ever once ruling Lower Egypt, or any part of Egypt. We then must take what the Biblical author writes to be true.

This brings me to my third point. How can you place slaves on the same column as kings? For the Hyksos in the history of Egypt were kings and ruled Lower Egypt for some time until the Theban rule of Upper Egypt fought to expel them. Israel had no intention of having a king at this time, and did not request a king until the time of Solomon and Saul. So if we are taking the Biblical writers to be truthful in their information, which Jacobovici thinks they were when they mentioned the storm and darkness in Exodus. Isn’t it interesting that IF the Israelites were the Hyksos, the rulers of Lower Egypt, wouldn’t the Bible have mentioned it? But no, in fact the first mention of an Israelite being king is with Saul. Also, lastly, the Pharaoh during the Exodus narrative fought rather hard against God to keep the Israelites as his slaves. Why would a Pharaoh who expelled the Hyksos and wanted them out of the land, along with most likely his father and all Theban rulers, fight so hard to keep the Israelites, if they are that Hyksos? So if we claim the Israelites as the Hyksos my last sentence would read like this: “Why would a Pharaoh who fought so hard to get the Hyksos out of rule, and the area itself, fight so hard to keep them as slaves?” It just doesn’t make sense. So from this we can conclude that the Hyksos and the Israelites are two very different types of people groups. It is broad speculation to put “foreign rulers,” kings, in the same category as the Egyptian forced labor, Israelite slaves.

The final thing I come to in this post is Simcha Jacobovici’s proof that the Israelites were the slaves of Egypt that the Bible asserts them to be. To retain this proof Jacobovici and his crew had to travel to Serabit El Khadim, and he quotes: “For thousands of years Egyptians mined turquoise in this area, often they used slave labor.” So if the Israelites were truly enslaved, as the Bible claims them to be, then this would be the place to find the evidence. Jacobovici continues “We came here to find proof of the slaves that Moses led to freedom. But even if we found evidence for the presence of slaves, how could we be sure that they were Israelites? The Bible provides us with two clues: first, the follower’s of Moses did not use Hieroglyphic writing like the Egyptians. Rather the Biblical tradition states that they used an early form of alphabetic writing. Also, the Israelites did not worship Egyptian gods, but a single god that the Bible calls ‘El.’” So the key for Jacobovici is to find both of these things in Serabit El Khadim, so does he succeed? The answer he gives us is: “And sure enough there are slave inscriptions here, and one of them records a 3500 year old cry, ‘El save me.’” So here again is archaeological proof, from Simcha Jacobovici’s documentary, that the Biblical author was not lying; the storm and darkness happened and the Israelites were indeed slaves. So why didn’t the Biblical author write of the great rule the Israelite kings had of Lower Egypt, and their reign, if they really are the Hyksos? Wouldn’t that be too much of an enormous event for the Biblical author to forget? The Egyptians sure didn’t forget the Hyksos rule. Also, then why is Saul mentioned as the first king or Israel, and the first Hyksos ruler isn’t even brought up? So, we come again to the title of this post; were the Israelites slaves, or kings?

Monday, June 6, 2011

Putting The Pieces Together Part I: One Man’s Search for The Exodus




The Exodus. It’s one of the first Bible stories you’re taught in Sunday school, but among Scholars and Archaeologist’s alike it’s one of the most controversial subjects of our time. Most Scholars today put the Exodus story in your typical bag of fairy tales and myths, and claim it was just made up. In the above video one man seeks to find out the truth of the Exodus, and I must say his findings are quite compelling. Simcha Jacobovici is a film director and producer, and has been searching for proof of the Exodus for some time. He starts his documentary by saying: “In the last scenes of a very famous movie The Lost Ark of The Covenant, the box that once held the Ten Commandments is crated and abandoned in the basement of a warehouse. What if Hollywood’s depiction accurately reflects reality? This would mean that hiding somewhere there is tangible proof of the story the Bible calls the Exodus. The deliverance of the Israelites from Egypt, led by the prophet Moses.” In Jacobovici’s documentary he seeks to find the truth and put together the pieces of the puzzle called the Exodus.

As with all things archaeological and historical the first thing we come to when dealing with an event in our history is the date. Dating an event like the Exodus takes a lot of research and study to be able to get the right outcome. To get the date he thinks is best suited for the Exodus Jacobovici uses some overlooked historical and archaeological facts and artifacts to piece together the Exodus puzzle. The first piece is an Egyptian Stele found in 1947 which is dated to 1500 B.C.E, and is connected to the Pharaoh Ahmose. Jacobovici describes the Stele as “Mirroring the Biblical tale” and that “Today it lies abandoned in the basement of the Cairo museum, and all our attempts to get access to it were unsuccessful.” Even with this difficulty though Jacobovici was able to reconstruct the Ahmose Stele, and asked a world-renown Egyptologist to comment. Professor Donald Redford states: “We have this very interesting Stele, which is dated to the reign of Ahmose. It records a tremendous catastrophe that happened to Egypt. We’re not quite clear what it was, but it involved rain, and thunder, and lightning, and such a storm that rarely happens in North East Africa. I mean that’s a dry area. It sounds peculiar to me that the Biblical tradition preserves the memory of plagues which involve climatic cataclysms, and here we have from the very time this curious Stele.” Jacobovici claims that the Ahmose Stele is “The key to the Exodus enigma,” and does a comparison between the Biblical account and the Stele, “The Bible says at the time of the Exodus there was a great storm. Ahmose’s Stele also talks of a great storm. The Bible says darkness descended on Egypt. The Stele says that Egypt was enveloped in darkness. The Stele then says something very peculiar. Though the Egyptians worshiped many gods, on this Stele it is written that the storm and the darkness happened when god, in the singular, manifested his power.”

With this we find that Ahmose’s Stele is the first piece of the puzzle for Jacobovici. He will then, from this first piece, start to place the rest of the pieces in order until the puzzle of the Exodus is completed. I am going to end this post here, but will continue to post on Simcha Jacobovici’s documentary The Exodus Decoded for as long as I need to. I am going to put a final quote from Jacobovici which deals with the nature of Ahmose’s name, but it is mere speculation and probability: “Can it be that Ahmose’s father remembered the Israelite prince he grew up with, and when he gave his son his Egyptian name Ahmose, The Moon is Born, he chose the name because of a play on words? In Hebrew the name Ahmose means The Brother of Moses.”